Español Deutsch

Running More, Gaining Weight? Here’s What Might Really Be Happening

You started running to lose weight. You’re putting in the miles, sweating through your workouts, maybe even paying more attention to what you eat. And yet, when you step on the scale, the number has gone up. Not down. Up. What the hell?

It’s one of the more frustrating experiences for new runners, particularly women who have been told for years that weight loss is a simple equation: move more, eat less, repeat. But the human body is considerably more complicated than a calorie calculator. Running can temporarily increase your weight without increasing body fat. It can make you hungrier, change how much water your body stores and, in some circumstances, expose a serious mismatch between how much energy you’re burning and how much you’re eating. And yes, sometimes running more really does coincide with gaining fat.

The important question isn’t simply why the scale is moving in the wrong direction. It’s what that movement actually represents, and whether it tells you anything useful about your health, fitness or training.

First Things First: Are You Actually Gaining Fat?

Before changing your diet or adding another five kilometres to your running schedule, consider what a bathroom scale measures. It doesn’t distinguish between fat, muscle, water, glycogen, food in your digestive system or the fluid you’ve just consumed. It measures everything together. That makes it particularly misleading when you’ve recently started exercising or increased your training volume.

One of the biggest reasons runners experience short-term weight increases is water retention. Your muscles store carbohydrates as glycogen, and glycogen is stored alongside water. When you begin training regularly, your glycogen stores may fluctuate more dramatically as you use fuel during exercise and replenish it afterwards. A higher-carbohydrate meal after a long run can therefore increase your weight without adding a corresponding amount of body fat.

You’ve probably heard that every gram of glycogen binds approximately three grams of water. It’s a useful illustration of the relationship, but not a reliable formula for predicting your weight. A study involving nine trained participants found that water storage during glycogen recovery varied considerably depending on fluid intake. The study involved demanding exercise and heat exposure, so its results shouldn’t be treated as a universal rule for recreational runners. Still, the underlying point stands: refilling your energy stores can make you heavier without making you fatter.

Why Your Muscles Might Be Holding More Water

There’s another reason your weight might increase after starting a running programme: your muscles are adapting to unfamiliar demands. Running, especially downhill running, faster intervals or a sudden increase in distance, can produce exercise-induced muscle damage. The resulting repair processes may involve temporary local swelling and fluid accumulation.

Research on muscle swelling following damaging exercise supports the existence of this response, although it doesn’t establish how much total body weight an ordinary runner should expect to gain. That distinction matters. It’s reasonable to consider exercise-related swelling as one possible explanation for a temporary increase, but not to declare that every unexplained kilogram is simply inflammation.

And what about muscle growth? Yes, running can produce muscular adaptations, particularly in beginners, but it isn’t usually a convincing explanation for a sudden substantial weight increase. Building meaningful amounts of muscle takes time, and endurance running doesn’t stimulate muscle hypertrophy in the same way as progressive resistance training. If you’ve also started lifting weights, changes in muscle mass may become more relevant over the longer term. But neither muscle growth nor water retention should become a convenient explanation for every number on the scale.

Do Women Retain More Water Than Men?

This is where the picture becomes particularly interesting for female runners. Both men and women experience exercise-related changes in glycogen, hydration and muscle recovery. Those mechanisms are not uniquely female. However, many women also experience fluctuations in fluid balance associated with their menstrual cycle, adding another variable to an already complicated equation.

In a 2023 study involving 42 women, researchers observed that average body weight during menstruation was approximately 0.45 kilograms higher than during the first week of the cycle. The difference was associated with increased extracellular water, meaning fluid outside the body’s cells.

That doesn’t mean every woman gains half a kilogram during her period, or that menstrual weight fluctuations always follow the same pattern. Some women notice bloating before menstruation, others during it, and some experience little noticeable change. Hormonal contraception, irregular cycles and the transition towards menopause can make these patterns even less predictable.

So do women gain more weight than men when they start running? We don’t have convincing evidence that they generally do. What we can say is that women with menstrual cycles may experience additional short-term fluctuations that complicate weight comparisons. A woman weighing herself at different points in her cycle might see changes unrelated to fat gain, even when her training and eating habits remain similar.

It’s also important not to confuse changes in fluid retention with changes in metabolism. Whether women burn more calories during different phases of their menstrual cycle is a separate question. A temporary increase in body water doesn’t automatically mean energy expenditure has risen or fallen.

The Hunger Trap: When Running Makes You Eat More

Now for the explanation nobody particularly enjoys hearing: sometimes increased running really does coincide with increased body fat, because food intake has risen enough to exceed the additional energy expenditure.

Running burns energy, but it can also stimulate appetite. A person who starts training regularly may find herself eating larger portions, reaching for more snacks or feeling unusually hungry in the evening. Sometimes the changes are obvious. Sometimes they’re subtle, particularly when exercise creates the impression that you’ve earned significantly more food than you actually need.

A 12-week study involving 24 women with overweight found that hunger and energy intake increased during a supervised aerobic exercise programme. Interestingly, the additional food only partly compensated for the energy expended through exercise, and participants still experienced a reduction in fat mass.

That result challenges the simplistic idea that increased hunger automatically cancels out exercise benefits. The study was small, non-randomised and lacked a non-exercising control group, so it cannot predict individual outcomes. But it demonstrates that eating more and losing fat are not mutually exclusive. The relationship depends on how much additional energy is consumed relative to what the body uses.

There’s another complication: people sometimes become less active outside their workouts. A demanding morning run might be followed by more sitting, fewer spontaneous walks or an unusually sedentary afternoon. This reduction in non-exercise activity can offset part of the energy expenditure from running. It’s not inevitable, and the size of the effect varies, but it’s worth considering when a training programme isn’t producing the expected changes.

And before you use your running watch to calculate exactly how much extra food you’ve earned, remember that wearable calorie estimates are imperfect. A study comparing three smartwatch models during outdoor walking and running found differences in energy-expenditure accuracy depending on the device and activity. Your watch can help track training, but its calorie display isn’t a precise nutritional prescription.

Underfueling vs. Overfueling: Two Very Different Problems

Here’s where the usual weight-loss advice starts to fall apart. Two runners can experience the same increase on the scale while facing completely different nutritional situations. One may be consuming more energy than she needs over time. The other may be failing to eat enough to support her training and basic physiological functions.

Overfueling, in the context of long-term energy balance, means consistently consuming more energy than the body expends. That surplus can lead to increased body fat over time. Running doesn’t make someone immune to this process, and a higher training volume doesn’t guarantee a calorie deficit. If body weight is rising steadily over several months, increased energy intake is one possible explanation worth investigating.

Underfueling is different. It means that food intake is insufficient for the body’s needs, particularly when exercise demands are taken into account. An athlete can consume what appears to be a substantial amount of food and still have inadequate energy available for recovery, hormonal function, bone health and other essential processes.

This becomes particularly important in the context of low energy availability and Relative Energy Deficiency in Sport, known as REDs. When insufficient energy availability becomes problematic, prolonged or severe, it can affect multiple physiological systems. Possible warning signs include disrupted menstrual cycles, recurrent bone stress injuries, persistent fatigue, poor recovery and declining performance.

And here’s the detail that frequently gets lost in social media discussions: you don’t have to be underweight, or even losing weight, to be underfuelled. Low energy availability can occur across different body sizes, and body weight alone cannot establish whether an athlete is eating enough.

That doesn’t mean underfueling magically creates body fat. The popular claim that eating too little automatically sends the body into a starvation mode that causes fat gain is misleading. Energy restriction can influence metabolic expenditure, spontaneous activity, appetite and fluid balance, but it doesn’t reverse the basic principles of energy balance. A person can experience temporary increases on the scale while underfuelled, yet a sustained increase in body fat still requires an energy surplus over time.

The distinction is crucial because the appropriate response may be completely different. Someone whose weight is rising because of a sustained energy surplus may benefit from reviewing intake and activity. Someone experiencing low energy availability may need to increase food intake, reduce training demands or both, ideally with guidance from a qualified sports dietitian or clinician.

The Study Where Gaining Weight Was Actually Good News

One of the most revealing examples comes from the REFUEL randomised trial, which investigated 76 exercising women with infrequent or absent menstrual periods. Researchers assigned participants either to increase their energy intake or to maintain it, examining whether additional food could help restore menstrual function.

The women assigned to eat more were more likely to experience a menstrual period. They also gained more body weight and body fat than those who maintained their intake.

Read that again. The women who gained more weight also experienced an improvement in an important marker of reproductive health.

For someone who associates weight gain with failed training, that result might initially sound discouraging. But the study wasn’t designed to produce weight loss. It investigated whether correcting inadequate energy availability could help restore a physiological function that had become disrupted.

Not every participant recovered normal menstrual function, and the return of a single period doesn’t guarantee complete hormonal recovery. Nevertheless, the findings demonstrate why weight changes cannot be interpreted independently of health.

A 2026 secondary analysis involving 25 participants provided additional insight. Women who achieved more sustained menstrual recovery showed better lumbar-spine bone-density outcomes. Because this was an analysis within the intervention group rather than a new randomised comparison, it cannot establish that menstrual recovery itself caused the differences in bone density. But it reinforces the importance of looking beyond body weight when evaluating an athlete’s condition.

The message isn’t that eating more makes you lose weight, or that every female runner should increase her calorie intake. It’s that weight gain can sometimes accompany an improvement in health, and weight loss isn’t always evidence that a training programme is working well.

Does Underfueling Affect Men and Women Differently?

Men are not immune to low energy availability or REDs. Male endurance athletes can experience hormonal disturbances, impaired bone health, reduced performance and other consequences when energy intake fails to support training demands. However, some warning signs differ between sexes, and certain effects may be easier to recognise in women.

For women who menstruate, changes in cycle regularity can provide an important signal that something may be wrong, although menstrual disturbances have multiple possible causes and are not diagnostic of REDs on their own. In men, hormonal changes may be less immediately visible, making problems harder to recognise without further assessment.

There are also important individual differences. Hormonal contraception can mask natural menstrual patterns, and not all women menstruate regularly for reasons related to energy availability. Neither sex can be assessed reliably using body weight, calorie intake or a single symptom alone.

So while female runners may face additional complexities related to menstrual function and cyclical fluid changes, the fundamental need to match nutritional intake with training demands applies to everyone.

How to Tell What’s Really Happening

When your running volume increases and your weight follows, the most useful clue is often the timescale. A sudden increase over a day or two is more likely to involve fluid, glycogen or digestive contents than a comparable amount of newly accumulated body fat. A gradual increase over several months deserves a broader look at eating habits, training load, activity outside workouts and changes in body composition.

Pay attention to how you feel, too. Are you recovering well between runs? Is your performance improving? Are you constantly hungry, unusually exhausted or struggling with recurring injuries? For women who menstruate naturally, have your periods become irregular or stopped altogether? These questions can reveal more about your training situation than a single number on the scale.

If weighing yourself is useful and doesn’t create anxiety or compulsive behaviour, compare measurements under similar conditions, ideally at a consistent time of day and, where relevant, a comparable point in your menstrual cycle. Looking at longer-term trends is generally more informative than reacting to individual readings. But weighing is optional, and for someone vulnerable to restrictive eating or obsessive tracking, more frequent measurements may do more harm than good.

Persistent unexplained weight changes also deserve medical attention because not everything is caused by running. Medication, pregnancy, thyroid disorders and other health conditions can influence body weight. And while temporary exercise-related swelling may be harmless, sudden, painful, red or hot swelling, particularly in one leg, requires prompt medical assessment. Swelling accompanied by chest pain or shortness of breath warrants emergency care.

Stop Treating the Scale Like a Performance Review

Running is supposed to challenge your body, not turn every morning into a referendum on whether you’ve succeeded. A higher number on the scale might mean you’ve replenished your glycogen stores, retained more water, changed your eating habits or gained body fat. It might reflect a combination of several factors. And occasionally, as the REFUEL researchers demonstrated, gaining weight can be part of restoring a healthier physiological balance.

None of this means body composition goals are invalid or that weight gain should always be celebrated. It means those goals need to be pursued with an understanding of what the body actually requires to train, recover and function properly.

Before you run farther or eat less to punish a disappointing weigh-in, find out what you’re actually trying to fix. Because the number on the scale can tell you how much you weigh. It can’t tell you whether you’re becoming a better, stronger or healthier runner.

Autor
  • Astrid Kramer

    Astrid Kramer is a writer, amateur athlete, and the founder of BADDAZZ. She writes about sport, strength, endurance, and the stories behind athletic performance. She is currently writing The Gender Sports Gap, a book exploring the forgotten history of women in sport.